Lo sbeffeggio generale decisamente ci sta.
Traduco dal Bessese:
manacheck = fare terraspellspell-terraspellspell-terraspellspell-...
6-pile-shuffling = suddividere le carte del mazzo in 6 pile diverse, mettendo la prima nella pila1, la seconda nella pila2, ..., la settimana nella pila1, l'ottava nella pila2, ...
stackato = impilato con un pattern specifico
E veniamo alla risposta.
Per il giocatore 1, la sorte è decisamente segnata. Fare mana-weaving e poi NON mescolare per bene il mazzo, viene considerato CHEATING, con le conseguenze del caso.
Per il giocatore 2, se l'ha fatto intenzionalmente, essendosi reso conto della "mischiata" del suo avversario, anche lui si troverebbe in un bel caso di CHEATING.
Per completezza ecco cosa dice il regolamento:
Penalty Guide ha scritto:
134. Tournament Error — Insufficient Randomization
Definition
A player unintentionally fails to sufficiently randomize their deck before presenting it to their opponent. A deck is not randomized if the judge believes a player could know the position or distribution of one or more cards in their deck. If the insufficient randomization was intentional, the infraction is Cheating — Manipulation of Game Materials.
Examples
A. A player in a Magic tournament forgets to shuffle his library after searching for a card.
B. A player in a Magic tournament searches for a card, then gives the deck a single riffle-shuffle before presenting the deck to her opponent.
Philosophy
Players are expected to randomize their deck thoroughly when it is required and are expected, especially at Competitive and Professional RELs, to have the skill and understanding of randomization to do so. Any time cards in a deck could be seen, including during shuffling, it is no longer randomized, even if the player only knows the position of one or two cards. Players are expected to take care in shuffling not to reveal cards to themselves, their teammates or their opponents.
Players are assumed to know the order of their cards before starting to shuffle and sufficient randomization means the player could not gain advantage from this knowledge. A player should randomize his or her deck using multiple methods. Patterned pile-shuffling alone is not sufficient randomization.
Any manipulation, weaving or stacking prior to randomization is acceptable, as long as the deck is thoroughly randomized afterwards. Doing so and not sufficiently randomizing afterwards is defined as Cheating — Manipulation of Game Materials.
